Unexpectedly impressed., 27 Sept. 2015

I have long lashes and so any mascara I use has a job to do, it has to be worthy and my expectations are high. Mustn't clump, must be quick to apply. Mustn't smudge or flake under any circumstances. This mascara ticks all those boxes, I popped it on with no eyeshadow or liner for a basic look...Extra plusses. It's very black and very glossy. It somehow really managed to make my lashes look even longer and more curled, it really opened up my eyes and made them look bigger. I seriously didn't think any particular mascara could be so outstanding.The one I have is a mini sample which was an extra goodie in a perfume sample box from The Perfume Society. I expected it must cost a fortune but I see here it's not much more expensive than my usual Max Factor. Hoorah!

This review is from: BENEFIT THEY'RE REAL BEYOND MASCARA - BLACK 8.5G (Misc.)

Disappointed, 5 Aug. 2015

Sorry don't know what other people are doing but my lashes didn't look amazing ! Have had better results from cheaper options Maybeline and Essence both a quarter of the price very disappointed

Verified Purchase This review is from: BENEFIT THEY'RE REAL BEYOND MASCARA - BLACK 8.5G (Misc.)

Product seems fine but didn't have a box or any card, 3 Nov. 2015

Product seems fine but didn't have a box or any card. As a present I haven't opened the mascara and am hoping it is in good new condition.

Verified Purchase This review is from: BENEFIT THEY'RE REAL BEYOND MASCARA - BLACK 8.5G (Misc.)