Great eye product for eye definition, 6 Aug. 2017

Verified Purchase This review is from: L'Oreal Paris Super Liner Eyeliner Smokissime 102 Brown Smoke (Personal Care)

Five Stars, 10 Sept. 2016

Verified Purchase This review is from: L'Oreal Paris Super Liner Eyeliner Smokissime 100 Black Smoke (Personal Care)

Use it as a fuzzy liner, not an eyeshadow, 22 Jan. 2016

I CHANGED MY MIND - SEE EDIT AT END OF REVIEW BELOW!!!!!!!!

I thought this would be an eyeliner in a smoky grey shade, but it's actually more like a powder shadow in a sponge applicator. I used it to apply the shadow to my lid and then my finger to blend it upwards to create the "smoky eye" look - I didn't find the applicator much use for that as it just delivers more and more of the colour rather than acting as a blending tool. I was able to use the tip of the applicator to deepen the colour next to my upper lashes, but I wouldn't call it an "eyeliner" as such as the line is too thick.

The effect was nice for evening and I would use it again (maybe with a traditional liquid liner for definition) but my two main complaints were that the shadow tends to go into creases on the lid after a few hours and it's also rather hard to get off. I used a liquid eye make up remover on a cotton pad but didn't succeed in removing it all - in the end I had...

This review is from: L'Oreal Paris Super Liner Eyeliner Smokissime 100 Black Smoke (Personal Care)