I brought this 5 months ago now and I loved it when i first got it, 25 April 2017

I brought this 5 months ago now and I loved it when i first got it. It was smooth and a bit tricky to apply because if you mess up it's hard to remove. It only last a month or two cause now the eyeliner is like a lump of clay, it ruined my eyeliner brush and it was impossible to apply. I had to throw it away.

Verified Purchase This review is from: e.l.f. Cream Eyeliner, Black, 0.17 Ounce (Personal Care)

Too heavy and clumpy for my liking., 13 Mar. 2017

I was disappointed to find this eyeliner to be quite heavy and the brush a little too thick to create a subtle and smooth line. I usually prefer to use a liquid eyeliner but thought I would try this for the pretty affordable price. Sadly, not precise enough for my liking but maybe with a thinner application brush bought seperately, this could work a little better!

Verified Purchase This review is from: e.l.f. Cream Eyeliner, Black, 0.17 Ounce (Personal Care)

Good eyeliner, 25 Mar. 2017

Nice eyeliner, the brush is quite "sharp" and when you apply the first coat, then want it to make it darker, the brush scraps the majority of the first coat.But it's good, it stays for enough time and it's dark. Would be good to use a different brush.

Verified Purchase This review is from: e.l.f. Cream Eyeliner, Black, 0.17 Ounce (Personal Care)